Welcome Guest

New Post
Hot Topic
New Poll
Moved Topic
Sticky Topic
No New Post
Old Hot Topic
Old Poll
Announcement
Closed Topic

Posting Disabled

Posting to these forums has been disabled. They will remain as "read only" for your convenience.
Please visit the new forums at http://www.my.speedtv.com/go/forum/viewboard to continue the conversation!

F1: Raikkonen’s Penalty That Never Was

Avatar for Adam Cooper

Speed Freak

RankRankRankRank

Total Posts:  395

Joined 

Finn should have been forced to start from the back of the grid in Monaco according to rules.

Rookie

Rank

Total Posts:  1

Joined  03/14/2008

I bet Dr VJ withed Kimi had started from the back!

Also, who'd a thunk that another team Would have recieved a penalty for giving Sutil "one up the chute"?

Ultimate Insider

RankRankRankRankRank

Total Posts:  695

Joined 

“When the three minute signal is shown all cars must have their wheels fitted"

Yeah but some rules don't apply to some teams..

Rookie

Rank

Total Posts:  1

Joined  05/31/2008

It may be true that rules don't always apply to all. Hamilton may be but back on the race track with a crane while others cannot even be pushed back on the track.

Avatar for Jrex

Rookie

Rank

Total Posts:  13

Joined  05/21/2008

It's a shame the way Speed TV only see wrong on Ferrari team; even the comments made during the transmission by those Three Stooges are pathetic, they should wear McLaren outfits on the air with a big British flag as a background.

Avatar for k31871

Legend

RankRankRank

Total Posts:  276

Joined 

Ferrari always gets away with bending/breaking the rules!!! If he'd been made to start from the rear, then maybe poor Sutil would've been able to finish in 4th place, instead of being taken out by Kimi!

Rookie

Rank

Total Posts:  1

Joined 

It'd be nice if we were all perfect, but we're human, as are the race stewards. People make mistakes, and that's what happened. I'm no Ferrari apologist, far from it, but Kimi WAS penalized, and finished out of the points, so no harm, no foul.

Rookie

Rank

Total Posts:  3

Joined  05/07/2008

Everone, this happens for the front runners in almost every year I can remember since the days of Stewart.

Avatar for Chino Devoti

Abnormal User

RankRankRankRankRankRank

Total Posts:  4904

Joined 

k31871 - 01 June 2008 08:20 PM
Ferrari always gets away with bending/breaking the rules!!! If he'd been made to start from the rear, then maybe poor Sutil would've been able to finish in 4th place, instead of being taken out by Kimi!


Sutil would not have scored points at Monaco

...Steward Paul Gutjahr confirmed: "We would have had to give him a 25-second penalty, because he overtook three cars under yellow flags after the Alonso-Heidfeld collision at the hairpin."

A 25-second penalty would have dropped Sutil from fourth to at least 10th place.

http://en.f1-live.com/f1/en/headlines/news/detail/080602093137.shtml

Signature:

FIA_dot_com

Avatar for Jrex

Rookie

Rank

Total Posts:  13

Joined  05/21/2008

You guys have to stop saying that if the "Finn" was penalized Sutil would been score 5 points for 4th place.BIG MISTAKE Sutil would be also penalized 'cause he passed two car under yellow flag, right after the crash between Alonso and Heidfeld. No excuses.Watch the Race guys, and stop to listen those Three Stooges